Unbelievably, a randomized managed trial of cabbage leaf wraps for arthritis was printed.
In a bit of the British Medical Journal referred to as “Minerva,” the place attention-grabbing little snippets are compiled, an image was printed of a girl who had taped a cabbage leaf to her knee. She mentioned that was the one measure that supplied reduction from the signs of her osteoarthritis. You can see the picture at 0:12 in my video Benefits of Cabbage Leaves on the Knee for Osteoarthritis. Some medical doctors responded with bemusement, and one other was amazed—“not amazed that a cabbage leaf was used, but that this was considered newsworthy.” That physician disclosed she could also be a bit biased, although, admitting to being a cabbage-leaf-user herself.
Wrote one other reader, “Freshly washed cabbage leaves are known in European folk medicine as the poor man’s poultice. There is nothing new about this ancient remedy used to help reduce all kinds of painful swelling…So there is nothing freakish or stupid about the woman pictured in Minerva who used it over her painful knee.” I didn’t understand it was such a sensitive subject.
Of course, how might we all know if it really works? We’d want a randomized managed trial of topical cabbage leaves for osteoarthritis, and we received simply that.
The examine: “Efficacy of Cabbage Leaf Wraps in the Treatment of Symptomatic Osteoarthritis of the Knee: A Randomized Controlled Trial.” How did the examine even get funded? A household basis stepped ahead and paid for it. I really like that. In truth, it was the inspiration of Germany’s former President and First Lady. After all, “Osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee is one of the most common chronic diseases among older adults.” So, why not check the results of cabbage leaf wraps?
Patients with confirmed osteoarthritis of the knees have been randomly assigned to one among three remedies for 4 weeks: a cabbage leaf on their knees each day, a topical ache gel containing an anti-inflammatory drug, or neither, simply “usual care.” (Even higher would have been a fourth group making use of iceberg lettuce leaves, for instance, however I’ll take what I can get.)
At 2:13 in my video, I present a graph of ache depth over the 28-day experiment. The topical gel didn’t work a lot better than doing nothing all, however the cabbage leaf remedy really labored in lowering ache depth. Overall, the examine “found that a 4-week application of CLWs [cabbage leaf wraps] was more effective than UC [usual care] with respect to pain, functional disability, and quality of life. It was, however, not superior to a 4-week application of topical medication” within the closing evaluation. Since cabbage leaves are “safe and may be used in the longer term,” why not give them a attempt you probably have osteoarthritis of the knee?
It additionally wouldn’t harm for those who ate some as effectively, as cabbage might have inside anti-inflammatory potential as effectively. In truth, the anti-inflammatory results might explain the well being advantages of cabbage and different cruciferous household greens. And I’m not simply talking about potent anti-inflammatory results in petri dishes, however in individuals, too. In one examine, ten days of broccoli consumption in people who smoke cut C-reactive protein ranges 40 p.c! Okay, however what about for arthritis?
In vitro, sulforaphane, the magic cabbage chemical, protects cartilage from destruction, suggesting {that a} eating regimen excessive in cabbage or different cruciferous greens “may be a useful measure either to prevent or to slow the progression of OA,” osteoarthritis. But, as you may see at 3:38 in my video, even when sulforaphane can protect cartilage cells in a petri dish, how do we all know the compound makes it into our joints after we eat it? I imply, nobody has ever achieved a examine the place individuals eat broccoli after which a needle is caught of their knee joints to test. No one, that’s…till now.
And, certainly, sulforaphane was detected within the synovial fluid of 40 sufferers with osteoarthritis after broccoli consumption, adopted by important epigenetic modifications of gene expression inside the joint. The subsequent step is to see if it may possibly really enhance the illness.
Knees aren’t the physique components cabbage has been examined on. Stay tuned for my video about the usage of cabbage leaves for mastitis!
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Cabbage leaves, generally known as “the poor man’s poultice” in European people drugs, have been used to assist cut back painful swelling.
- One of the commonest persistent illnesses amongst older adults is osteoarthritis of the knee.
- Researchers randomized osteoarthritis sufferers to one among three teams for a month: cabbage leaves on their knees each day, a topical ache gel containing an anti-inflammatory, or nothing however “usual care.” The every day cabbage leaf wraps have been simpler than traditional care close to ache, useful incapacity, and high quality of life, however not in comparison with a month of topical treatment software.
- Since cabbage leaves are “safe and may be used in the longer term,” they could be price attempting to alleviate ache attributable to osteoarthritis of the knee.
- Eating cabbage may be useful, as cruciferous greens have confirmed anti-inflammatory results. For occasion, people who smoke lowered their C-reactive protein ranges by 40 p.c after solely ten days of consuming broccoli.
- Sulforaphane, a potent chemical in crucifers, has been proven in vitro to guard cartilage from destruction.
- When studied in individuals as a substitute of a petri dish, sulforaphane was certainly detected within the synovial fluid of osteoarthritis sufferers after broccoli consumption.
For extra on pure remedies for arthritis, see:
What’s that sulforaphane stuff I discussed? Check out:
In well being,
Michael Greger, M.D.
PS: If you haven’t but, you may subscribe to my free movies right here and watch my stay displays:
Discussion about this post